Stablecoin v. ACH: What the Metrics Actually Show
Stablecoin transaction headlines generate attention. Institutional adoption, however, is much more difficult.
Reports suggest that stablecoins have just “beaten” ACH on total volume and, therefore, are on track to replace traditional payments rails. Once you align the statistics and use cases properly, the story reads more like coexistence than conquest.
Artemis data shows that stablecoins briefly overtook ACH in February, settling about $7.2 trillion in adjusted 30-day on-chain dollar volume versus roughly $6.8 trillion for ACH over the same period. That's the eye-catching news peg behind a wave of LinkedIn, X, and business media articles claiming that stablecoins are overtaking the U.S. financial system's payments infrastructure.
The problem is that the headlines mismatch what the two systems do in the real economy, the place where the corporate and institutional adoption that matters occurs.
Stablecoins Beat ACH
The headline that started my 2026 focus on stablecoins, and the two ways to read it
The headline comparison
Measures all token movement: trading, collateral, treasury shifts, arbitrage
Stablecoins ≈ ACH
The payments comparison
Measures actual payments: payroll, payables, bills, B2B transfers
Stablecoins ≈ 0.4% of ACH
Source: Artemis via CoinMarketCap; McKinsey/Artemis; Nacha
Adoption, Not Attention
I'm not arguing that growth and interest in stablecoins — clearly this year's model — are unimportant as future infrastructure or lack valid use cases.
I am pointing out that focusing on media headline numbers or the marketing vanity metrics, interesting though they may be, is not a real indicator of product adoption. From a product perspective, it's a matter of use cases and cost efficiencies. For most U.S. uses, payments are not at the top of the institutional stablecoin list.
Consider the results from the latest Association of Financial Professionals (AFP) digital payments survey. Only 13% of respondents reported that they were "very familiar" or "familiar" with stablecoins. The total increased to 34% for tokenized purchases (money markets, deposits, repo, etc.), underscoring that tokenization of traditional assets is currently ahead of pure stablecoin payments in mindshare.
Stablecoin flows are mostly collateral movements, treasury shifts, and trading infrastructure — call it money movement. ACH flows are one-off credits and debits tied to corporate accounts payable, salaries, Social Security, mortgages, electric bills, and anything else that people think of when they hear "payments."
If you isolate payments from raw token movement, the picture changes fast. A recent McKinsey and Artemis analysis puts true stablecoin payment volume at about $390 billion in 2025, after stripping out exchange internal transfers, arbitrage, and smart-contract noise. That is just 0.02% of global payments volume, with about 60% of stablecoin payments coming from B2B use cases such as cross-border supplier and treasury flows.
Making a payments-to-payments comparison on $390 billion in global stablecoin payments versus $93 trillion in U.S. ACH payments is where the headlines break down. That's a long way from "stablecoins are replacing the U.S. payments system" and a misuse of the ACH comparison. There's a big difference between attention and adoption, especially in corporate and institutional payments.
ACH and Other Bank Payments
ACH remains the Main Street of U.S. personal, corporate, and government money movement. NACHA's latest numbers show the network processed 35.2 billion payments in 2025, totaling $93 trillion in value, up 7.9% in value and 4.9% in volume from 2024. Same Day ACH is experiencing a growth spurt, moving $3.9 trillion last year, a growth rate of more than 20%.
Parallel to ACH and card network value exchange systems, U.S. financial institutions run a growing cluster of faster and instant payments: RTP, FedNow, Zelle, and card-based push payments. In 2025 RTP settled $1.45 trillion and FedNow $853 billion, together about $190 billion a month; Zelle moved $1.2 trillion in mostly P2P and small-business flows; and Visa Direct carried more than 12.5 billion transactions in its fiscal 2025 without disclosing their value.
Looked at that way, faster payments and P2P apps are less an alternative to ACH and more another layer of specialized plumbing. Much like stablecoins, they are designed to handle time-sensitive or cross-platform use cases while the ACH network continues to function as the core domestic payments backbone.
Again, the problems and volumes need to be aligned with the appropriate use cases for the many available U.S. payment solutions.
U.S. Payment Rail Landscape: Where Stablecoins Fit
| Payment rail | Value | Count | Settlement / speed | Limit per payment | 24/7 | Primary use | Published price signal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ACH Network | $93T (2025, U.S.) | 35.2B | Deferred net; next day or same day | No network cap | No | Payroll, bills, B2B, government | Bank-priced; not published |
| Same Day ACH (subset of ACH) | $3.9T (2025) | 1.4B | Deferred net; hours | $1M | No | Urgent payroll, same-day B2B | Bank-priced; not published |
| Fedwire Funds | $1,148T (2025) | 217.3M | RTGS; real time in operating hours | None | No | High-value and interbank settlement | Bank-priced; not published |
| CHIPS | $2.0T per business day (2025 avg.) | 630K+ per day | Real-time final, with netting | None | No | High-value USD, incl. cross-border | Participant-priced |
| RTP | $1.45T (2025); $621B in Q3 2026 | 447.2M (2025) | RTGS; seconds | $10M | Yes | Account transfers, bill pay, disbursements | Bank-priced to customers |
| FedNow | $853B (2025); $275B in Q2 2026 | 8.4M (2025) | RTGS; seconds | $10M | Yes | Account transfers, liquidity management | $0.045 per credit transfer; $25 monthly fee (2026 schedule, to banks) |
| Zelle | $1.2T (2025) | 4.2B | Bank network; minutes | Set by bank | Yes | P2P, small business | Bank-priced; not published |
| Visa Direct | Not disclosed | 12.5B+ (FY2025) | Deferred net; minutes | $50K per OCT | Varies | Push-to-card disbursements, P2P, cross-border payouts | Negotiated; not published |
| Mastercard Send | Not disclosed | Not disclosed | Deferred net; minutes | $10K–$50K by use case | Varies | Push-to-card disbursements, P2P | Negotiated; not published |
| Stablecoins (payments) | $482B Jan–Sep 2026 (global); ~$390B 2025 | 1.04B Jan–Sep 2026 | On-chain, final; seconds | None at network | Yes | Cross-border B2B, P2P, payroll, card-linked | $2–$125.50 per $1,000 cross-border, sum of FPC cost ranges |
| Stablecoins (all on-chain transfers) | $97.9T Jan–Sep 2026 (global) | — | On-chain, final; seconds | None at network | Yes | Mostly trading, DeFi, exchange and automated flows; not payments | Gas fee only: $0–$50 per $1,000 (FPC) |
| Tokenized deposits | Not disclosed | Not disclosed | On-chain bank ledger, final; seconds | None at network | Yes | Corporate treasury, intrabank cross-border | Bank-priced; not published |
Sources: Nacha 2025 ACH Network statistics; Federal Reserve Financial Services, Fedwire Funds annual statistics, FedNow volume and value statistics and FedNow 2026 fee schedule; The Clearing House, RTP annual statistics and CHIPS 2025; Zelle 2025 results; Visa fiscal 2025 Form 10-K; U.S. Faster Payments Council, Comprehensive Look at the U.S. Faster Payments Landscape (Sep 10, 2026) for settlement, speed and limits, and The Economics of Stablecoin for Cross-Border Transactions (Oct 8, 2026); Allium, State of Stablecoins and Payments, Q3 2026 (Oct 15, 2026); McKinsey with Artemis (Feb 2026). U.S. rails are operator-reported; stablecoin figures are global third-party estimates and not directly comparable. Swift is omitted: it is a messaging network and does not publish payment value. The FPC stablecoin cost sum adds every element’s low and high range; not every element applies to every payment. Compiled October 16, 2026.
Whither Stablecoins and Tokenization?
Traditional payments and digital finance are starting to converge in bank-issued tokens like Societe Generale-FORGE's USD CoinVertible. Northern Trust Co., in its Q1 2026 earnings call, noted it onboarded new digital asset clients providing custody for tokenized real-world assets, U.S. stablecoins, and carbon credits, and launched a tokenized share class to broaden global liquidity vehicles.
The LinkedIn and X celebrations get the direction of travel right — stablecoins are becoming serious financial infrastructure — but their misuse of the ACH comparison obscures where real institutional adoption is happening, how many alternatives are developing, and how far any payments innovation has to go to compete seriously.
Aaron Brown, Bloomberg Opinion, April 15, 2026 "The cypherpunks foresaw all of these use cases with remarkable precision: frictionless cross-border settlement, aid disbursement without intermediaries, complex multi-currency transactions handled cleanly. They just assumed the underlying unit of account would be something anarchic and stateless. It is, instead, the currency of the United States federal government. Big brother."
Selected Bibliography
- Aaron Brown, "The Cypherpunks Wanted to Destroy the Dollar. They Saved It Instead," Bloomberg Opinion, April 15, 2026.
- Artemis data, "Stablecoins Surpass ACH Volume for the First Time," April 2, 2026.
- Association of Financial Professionals (AFP), "2025 AFP Digital Payments Survey."
- McKinsey / Artemis, "Stablecoin Payments Surge to $390 Billion in 2025," February 2026.
- NACHA, "ACH Network Volume and Value Statistics," 2025–2026.
- Northern Trust Co., Q1 2026 Earnings Call, April 21, 2026.
- Payments Dive, "Stablecoins Remain Little Used for Payments," April 13, 2026.
- Allium, "State of Stablecoins and Payments, Q3 2026," October 15, 2026.
- U.S. Faster Payments Council, "A Comprehensive Look at the U.S. Faster Payments Landscape," September 10, 2026, and "The Economics of Stablecoin for Cross-Border Transactions," October 8, 2026.
Page History
10 reader-facing changes since 2026-05-29; last change 2026-10-19 (v1.1.1).
Show all changes
| Date | Release | Change |
|---|---|---|
| 2026-10-19 | v1.1.1 | Rail landscape converted to a native table with linked sources; prose aligned to published 2025 rail figures |
| 2026-10-19 | v1.1.1 | U.S. payment rail landscape rebuilt with October 16, 2026 figures (operator-reported values, Faster Payments Council cost ranges) |
| 2026-10-18 | v1.1.1 | Q3 2026 scores presented as a 0–100 Digital Money Adoption index with a native viability matrix and Digital Money Verdicts; Seller Profiles added; buyer, roadmap, regulatory, glossary and directory updates |
| 2026-10-15 | v1.1 | Q3 2026 DMA score tables on Measurement & Analysis; Solution Viability Matrix moved after the demand vectors; Stablecoin v. ACH rail landscape image path fixed |
| 2026-09-14 | v0.9 | Release change to v0.9. Added DMA score, combined Use Cases with Adoption, rewrote the score overview page, updated roadmap, and posted the 09-14 News Digest. note to home plus roadmap changes |
| 2026-07-12 | v0.8 refresh | Edits to Use Cases Overview and ACH graphic |
| 2026-07-12 | v0.8 refresh | Added Use Case Overview and a Roadmap section. Updates Use Case and Adoption articles. |
| 2026-07-12 | v0.8 refresh | Added Use Case Overview, Updated Use Case pages, and a Roadmap section. |
| 2026-07-12 | v0.8 refresh | Added Use Case Overview, Updated Use Case pages, and a Roadmap section. |
| 2026-05-29 | v0.7 | v0.6: initial commit - 1st MkDocs build, all docs as of 05-14-2026 |
Infrastructure and formatting commits are omitted. Release-level detail is in the Release Notes.